About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

Disabled gamer case study: Why I like the games I like

Tera Kirk's picture

I used to be scared of The Legend of Zelda. It was the kind of delicious terror that you feel when you cover your eyes during a scary movie and peek through your fingers. There were no walls; I could go in any direction, but there were no signs to tell me which to take. (The original Mega Man had the same effect on me, but in a different way). Without the tunnel vision of Super Mario Bros., I tread carefully up a river, across a bridge and into a tree. "I found the first level!" I thought, reading the upper-right corner of the screen. And then, "Wait a minute. I don't find things."

A lot of games I like are about running around finding things. Although I only know where a few places are in my town and go everywhere else with my mother or a friend, I've remembered the layout of Hyrule in A Link to the Past without having played it for years. While I have a lot of trouble navigating 3-dimensional space that I'm physically in, it's much easier to find my way around a 2D expanse on a screen.

Neuroscience and the MRI I had when I was 12 can tell you why. I have some periventricular leukomalacia (PVL), which is a fancy Greek term for "some white matter around the brain's ventricles has died." Because of the skillset I have, I've also been diagnosed with nonverbal learning disabilities (NLD). Most of the dead white matter is in my right parietal lobe, which is a mapmaker: it makes maps of where one is in external space, and internal maps of one's body parts--particularly the left ones. So people with right parietal damage can lack awareness of the left side of their bodies, as well as the left half of space. They can also have trouble with spatial orientation in a more general way.

My spatial cognition is good for some things, bad for others. I interpret an object seen from different angles as being several different things. This kind of thinking is handy for distinguishing letters: recognizing one shape flipped four ways (b, p, q, d) as four separate objects. But letter-vision is not good for recognizing a building that looks different to you depending on how you come to it.

Letter-vision is better—not good, but better—for video games. They exist on flat screens, in two dimensions; no matter how advanced the graphics engine is, a building in a game cannot be seen from as many perspectives as it can in real life.

I play a lot of slower-paced games with lots of text. As a kid, I thought Dragon Warrior was the coolest game ever because almost everything I did--walking down stairs, opening chests, fighting monsters--I did in writing.(I lied; letter-vision is good for video games).

First-person shooters are hardest for me; I don't know if it's the illusion of maneuvering my own body through space, as opposed to controlling another person remotely, or what. I do like a couple, though, including the BioShock demo. And I've got my eye on this cool one-button FPS contest.

A lot of computer games are more difficult for me than console games. Because I'm not fully aware of my left side, it's 40% weaker than my right (the fancy Greek word for such weakness is hemiparesis) and not all the fingers on my left hand are mapped correctly to my brain. My middle and ring fingers are tied together somehow. While I learned to type, my fingering is unconventional; though I can type "was" and "sad," I have a much harder time using those letters to maneuver someone. It's better if I can map movement to the arrow keys and use W, A, S and D for stuff I don't need as often, or as all-at-once. For this reason, I like games that can be played just with a mouse. Yes, I am drooling over Diablo III. And playing the Hello Kitty Online beta. (Hush). Similarly, I like Games for Windows titles that have support for XBox 360 controllers.

When I have disability-related problems with a game, what I want is more options. I want to do things differently than the way a game is forcing me to do them. One the one hand, the multisensory nature of games seems well-suited to give players this customizability. But on the other, it seems a lot of creators think of their game's multisensory experience as a package deal: we need all that sensory input to play. There really is authorial control in games, and to be more accessible game makers will have to let go of some of it.

Category Tags
Articles: Best Work  
Topic(s): Gaming with Disabilities  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Fascinating stuff, Tera...

Fascinating stuff, Tera... very enlightening. thanks for posting that.

Couldn't agree more

I would love to see many options for all kinds as well. A developer should try as much as they can to bring in as many people as possible. I know its probably tough to do this, but I hope it becomes easier in the future.

That's fascinating, Tera.

That's fascinating, Tera. For a number of years, my hands were so messed up that I could only use a computer for minutes before I started experiencing pain. During that time, I developed a number of workarounds to get schoolwork done (dictating work, creating a foot controlled mouse). I also developed new ways to play my guitar. I find it interesting to hear how you have made videogames work for you.

Tom Clancy's Endwar might be

Tom Clancy's Endwar might be something you'd want to look at, that can be controlled almost completely through voice and its really quite impressive as far as technology goes. There's even a video on youtube of 2 parrots playing it! Sadly I find the game is rather dull but I hope it's successful so the technology will be implemented more in a wider variety of games

Thanks for your insights

Thanks for your insights

Really interesting

One of the most interesting things I have read on the internet this month, it really gives me an idea of all the problems some people face in all subjects.

this is the best game site on the web, more than just game x will be the greatest game ever!
2 months later game x 4/10

Enlightening

Thanks for posting this Tera.

If the gaming public and development community had more access to the (life and) gaming experiences of more gamers with disabilities--especially ones as interesting and nicely written as yours--games would be a lot less restrictive and therefore more inclusive experiences.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.