About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

What if Mario were a Jew?

Matthew Kaplan's picture

New Super Mario Bros. Wii Art

Both Assassin's Creed titles open with a message from the design team:

This work of fiction was designed, developed and produced by a multi cultural team of various religious faiths and beliefs.

It's a very nice, safe message from Ubisoft... and until recently, I never realized why it bothered me. Religion isn't really a major factor in either game. This, despite repeated mention of the "Templars," Altair's (and protagonist Desmond Miles') possible Muslim heritage, and the first game's setting in the Holy Land. (Actually, at the time of playing the first game, I did wonder why there seemed to be so few Jews in Jerusalem, but I digress....)

Religion may not be the point of Assassin's Creed, but certainly it's inherent in the setting, the context. Why the lack of attention? Is the development team really walking on eggshells, or is this symptomatic of a larger phenomenon in video games?

One can very reasonably argue that religion does not play a role in most video games (other than those which are "edutainment" or pointedly religious to the point of proselytizing, ala the Left Behind series) for the same reason that many cultural and ethnic factors do not: It's just not part of what we look for in an avatar. You don't really see a "Buddhist" slider in the Elder Scrolls character creation screen, after all.

But is that really the case? That games remain pleasantly ignorant of religion and ethnic culture because we will them to do so? The Grand Theft Auto series, for all its problems, has done a stunning job of playing with our expectations of character and narrative based on stereotypes. Between Niko's unlikely friendship with homosexual Russian Florian "Bernie Crane" Cravic and Lost and the Damned's Jewish protagonist Johnny Klebitz, there's a great deal of room for subtlety, yes, but at least Rockstar is trying to texture its characters with all the personal dimensions that come with being part of a melting pot culture. Why? Probably because Rockstar realizes, as we all most likely do when paying attention, that compelling fiction—even the interactive sort—borrows from, and contributes to, our sense of self.

I'm not arguing for cultural sensitivity here; rather, an increased attention to culture's religious dimensions. I ask the question in the title of this post, not to be incendiary, but rather to truly posit, "What if the character that billions of children and adults all over the world identify with happened to be a Jew?"

Growing up Jewish in the Baptist Belt of America, I often wished as a child that there were more Jewish heroes with whom I could identify. Comics got it right occasionally (e.g., X-Men's Kitty Pryde), but video games certainly missed out. I'm sure Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus and other members of religious minorities in the Western world must feel the same way. And I'm not excluding a lack of religion, either: There's plenty of room for atheist heroes. But why dump one's head in the sand altogether?

I think the misconception, perhaps for all fiction, is that when an author refers offhandedly to a character's faith or ethnicity, it has to be supported with substantial reasoning that is made crystal clear for the reader/viewer/player. For example, if Altair had been made pointedly Muslim, it would have had to have been for a pretty damn good reason, what, in this age of anti-Muslim sentiment and wars in the Middle East.

I do not believe that is true. I think people, in general, just happen to come from a beautiful range of backgrounds... and religion just happens to be one of the colors in that spectrum. Why don't we treat our characters the same way? Sure, if the game happens to justify its inclusion of religion with a meaningful and substantial treatment of the topic, more power to it. If it doesn't end up being integral to the plot or gameplay, fine. By no means should it be a requirement.

It is true that invoking religion—just as it has been so with gender and race—opens the door to stereotyping. No one wants to see, let's say, hook-nosed villain Izzy Shlomowitz as a star in an Aryan Brotherhood-designed platformer for the PC. Not any more than homosexual men and women probably want to see the kind of gay-smearing, prissy stereotyping that comes out of some Japanese RPGs.

But that's life. Life opens the door to unimaginable evils. Better to face it than to pretend we're not part of the conversation. And for better or worse, video gaming has achieved the level of cultural penetration to the point that it is completely inextricable from that conversation.

So what if Mario were a Jewish-Italian plumber? Well, he'd still be Mario. Only Jewish.

I kind of like that.

P.S. Yes, I'm aware of the irony of the whole "Jewish Mario/coin collecting" thing. I do have a sense of humor, after all.

Category Tags
Platform(s): Xbox 360   Wii   PS3   Nintendo DS  
Articles: Editorials  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Can you bring in religion as

Can you bring in religion as a part of cultural stereotype without stereotyping someone's God, though?
That is, when you leave God and Religion out, you're not beholden to satisfy the moral expectations of whoever's religon you're including in what you're writing. Sometimes not, though.

using a cinema comparison I found several reviews of the movie 'Castaway' on Amazon, written by admitted Christians who felt that the movie was 'abandoning God' by not having Tom Hanks pray to God to be rescued. ie- they thought it was a 'BAD' movie, because we didn't SEE Tom Hanks (who I guess must be Christian?) pray.

Now, if you include a scene where they delineate his character in terms of faith, does it strengthen or undermine the rest of the narrative? IMO it would undercut the message of self determination, and water down his eventual rescue (however, speaking metaphorically, I think the whale that follows him at the end is representative of something higher, but alot of people who want faith portrayed in entertainment don't want subtlety- they want it big and loud and in your face, which to me is indicative of a problem that Im not going to get into here)....

Anyway, I think most entertainment defines its own morality by the actions of its characters.
Sure, there's exceptions, but in a medium (videogames) that's generally rife with violence, do you really want to introduce God as a storytelling prop? It's murky territory, imo.

But I do think bringing out more cultural reference is a great idea. I would love to see a game that brought home the generational struggle and growth of the refugee family in America. Coming from somewhere else, and overcoming odds and prejudice while retaining cultural identity IS the American experience ...

How tactfully it can be done is an interesting point to consider.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.