You're only nominating 1.5 games!?
Fallout 3 called, it wants its Alien Blaster back.
I'm wholeheartedly behind you with RDR
. When I played it first I agreed with the people who said it was a bit Grand Theft Pony. However, with time, and a replay of the game, I've become hugely impressed by it. I think I may have said before that I think it is the absolute pinnacle of the Cinematic Action Game.
The acting was superb, the main characters sympathetic, the story excellent, the whole mood of the game segued perfectly with the passing of the West. Stunning scenery, a fantastic world, just great.
8/10 from me.