Those Journey votes are weird. IGN? Didn't Halo come out this year?
/sarcastic internet person
Tim, I laughed out loud at your Dead Island WTF. Very well done.
Updated Ratings (with Kin and Tim's votes 
)
XCOM is the out and out winner with 15 pts now.
9pts
Borderlands 2
Mass Effect 3
5 pts
The Walking Dead
Sleeping Dogs
OOTP 13
FTL
Tribes: Ascend
Spec Ops: the Line
Uncharted Golden Abyss
4 pts
Papo and Yo
Assassin's Creed 3
Skyrim (eh?)
Devil Survivor 2
Tales from Space: Mutant Blobs Attack
Dragon's Dogma
3 pts
Minecraft
Retro/Grade
I am Alive
Forza Horizon
2 pts
Guild Wars 2
Endless Space
Cut the Rope Experiments (Free)
FIFA Street
1pt or less
Mists of Pandaria 1 pt
Legend of Grimrock 1 pt
Natural Selection 2 1 pt
Ceramic Destroyer 1 pt
Waves 0.5 pts
That has changed the landscape quite a bit....