Re: 2011 Community GOTY
GOTY - Alice: Madness Returns
Why? Old skool 3d platforming done right! Combat system intuitive, fluid but challenging. Plus, outstanding art direction and overall atmosphere.
Worst game of the year - Fable III
(2011 release on PC, although technically a late 2010 Xbox 360 game.)
One word: lazy. Combat system shallow, dungeon/field design one-dimensional, social interactions vapid, economy system tedious. Such a let-down since the premise (and first 2 or so hours) of the game was so promising.