About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City Review

Brad Gallaway's picture

Don't Knock the Farmer

Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City Screenshot

High Wiping the floor with enemies who wiped the floor with you earlier.

Low Adding a new class mid-game can mean a lot of painful leveling-up.

WTF Would it really kill the game to have the experience accrue just a bit faster?

When I originally reviewed Etrian Odyssey II: Heroes of Lagaard, I had no idea what to expect. I had heard it was old-school and really difficult, but beyond that I didn't have a lot of information. I had braced myself for a painful experience, but was quite surprised to find a very superb game which took a classic formula and updated it in all the right ways. It was hardcore to be sure, but ended up an extremely fair and satisfying play.

Frankly, I was doubtful that Atlus could top that experience with Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City, but top it they did. While the core game is relatively unchanged from the previous two titles, there are enough improvements and additions to make it the most well-rounded and pleasantly polished Etrian so far.

For those new to the series, expect a first-person dungeon crawl that features tons of grinding for experience, frequently going broke buying equipment that only increases a character's strength by two points, drawing a map by hand through floor after floor of twisting labyrinth, and being crushed by random encounters in the first round of battle.

Still here? Good.

Set inside a giant, multi-story labyrinth, The Drowned City features a thin plot (basically: go explore!) and asks players to put together a party of five characters before sallying forth into the salivating, open, and all-too-hungry jaws of danger. It's a rough start that places much emphasis on player experimentation, but what helps this experience avoid feeling like punishing drudgery is that despite all the deaths and difficulties to come (and they will come) the game begins to open up once a player learns the rules and understands what's being asked of them. It may take a while, but the rules of play are simple to learn and the feeling of achievement is much more substantial when it's earned after so many hard knocks.

However, the developers have tossed in a few bones to make things easier for first-timers—believe it or not, The Drowned City is by far the easiest of the Etrian titles.

Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City Screenshot Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City Screenshot
Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City Screenshot Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City Screenshot

The biggest changes that benefit the player are the addition of two new character classes: the Prince and the Farmer. While the positive sides of these classes may initially seem less appealing than the straightforward damage-dealing of the Gladiator or the traditional healing spells of the Monk, I can't recommend them enough.

The Prince is relatively weak in combat, but more than makes up for it by employing "royal" powers. For example, at the end of each round of battle, he can heal every member in the party with no expenditure of magic points. Anyone who's got any experience playing RPGs is sure to see the incredible value in such an ability. Throw in low-cost elemental buffs and a few other interesting status-altering effects, and the Prince quickly becomes the backbone of any group.

The Farmer's offense is even weaker than the Prince's, but proves to be instrumental in building a strong team. Thanks to supplemental fortifications like multiplying experience earned, proficiency at gathering rare and valuable resources, and enhancing the restorative effects of mid-dungeon resting points, he's a must-have. The Farmer may not be incredibly useful in the late game, but he is a godsend at the beginning, and for a great while afterwards.

Besides these fantastic new classes (and two more hidden away) Etrian Odyssey III also sports an overworld where players can board a ship and sail the ocean in search of rare items and other bonuses for use in the main dungeon. This little bit of oceangoing provides a nice break for when subterranean punishment is coming on a little strong, and the different mechanics of ship travel mean that the player's brain is being tested in different ways.

It's also possible to partake of some co-op in the ocean area, although the function is quite limited. So much so, in fact, that I debated whether to even mention it in this review. The thought of having a partner to adventure with certainly seems like it would be an incredible addition to such a difficult title, but the reality is that friends are only able to join together to fight very specific, non-campaign boss battles. When the battle is over, so is the co-op. I'm sad to say that this mode comes off as poorly-thought-out and not very balanced, and after taking on a few fights with a partner, we each expressed our mutual disappointment and never came back to it.

Aside from the misstep of the stunted co-op mode, every other aspect of Etrian Odyssey III has been vetted and manicured to ensure that the game provides the highest quality dungeon-crawling conceivable. Once accustomed to the steep difficulty of the encounters, I suspect that most players with a discerning eye will find that (like its predecessors) Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City is a shining example of old-school design infused with new-school wisdom. Rating: 8.0 out of 10.

Disclosures: This game was obtained via publisher and reviewed on the DS. Approximately 35 hours of play were devoted to the single-player mode, and the game was not completed at the time this review was written, though the Critic is still playing. Two hours of play were spent in multiplayer mode.

Parents: According to the ESRB, this game contains alcohol and tobacco references, mild fantasy violence, language, and suggestive themes. Despite all those warnings, there really isn't have anything to worry about. Suggestive Themes? Mild Language? I don't have the faintest clue what these labels are referring to. The Alcohol Reference is (I assume) since one of the areas in the game takes place in a bar. The Mild Fantasy Violence amounts to seeing a "whoosh!" visual effect as an invisible weapon strikes a monster who shows absolutely no reaction. This isn't violence, it's the faint suggestion of violence... against fantasy monsters... with no animation. I'd be quite comfortable letting my nine-year-old play this game, assuming he could get over the difficulty curve.

Deaf & Hard of Hearing Gamers: You will have no problems whatsoever.  I played about 50% of the game without any sound, and encountered no barriers.  All dialogue in the game is presented through text, and since it's a turn-based combat engine, there is no need to rely on sound cues or anything aural. All important information is presented on-screen, and the experience is completely accessible from start to finish.

Category Tags
Platform(s): Nintendo DS  
Developer(s): Atlus  
Publisher: Atlus  
Series: Etrian Odyssey  
Genre(s): Role-Playing  
ESRB Rating: Everyone 10+  
Articles: Game Reviews  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

You made a happy man

«believe it or not, The Drowned City is by far the easiest of the Etrian titles»

I am inclined to believing you, and you just made a happy man. I know, I know, claiming I'm a fan of the Etrian series and yet I'm glad they tuned down the difficulty might sound strange, but the fact is, even though I played the first two games to death (lots of) I never got to complete either of them. I stopped being good at dungeon crawlers after the first Diablo, and I remember clearly having my ass kicked countless times in Diablo II and how I thought: «OK, I'm done with the genre».

Maybe I lack the patience (but it'd be odd: I still play a lot of turn-based strategy and Simcity-like games), maybe I just became stupid, but after the umpteenth cheap death at the hands of a lvl 1 Worthless Harmless Defenseless Blob I tend to grow tired of the game, no matter what it is. Or maybe the problem is just with turn-based battles and, mostly, with random encounters. I loathe random encounters, and I don't care about icons glowing red to signal nearby enemies or stuff like that. I just despise not being able to choose whether to fight or not. I simply do not enjoy the scenery, the landscape, the atmosphere. Random encounters break the immersion in (IMHO) an excusable way.

Yet, the first two Etrians blew my mind, with a simple yet ingenious trick: the map drawing. I would have enjoyed the games even with no enemies at all in the labyrinth. Being able to draw your own map reminds me of when I was young (like, really young) and my dad showed me Colossal Cave (or Adventure, of whatever you call it) and the huge amount of hand-drawn maps he and my mother made during the years – when I was still a sperm and they had a lot more time to have fun :-D. I found the first Etrian Odyssey to be unforgiving yet unbelievably charming, and I really, really tried to get to the end of it. Nope. No way. I'm no good, I guess.

BUT! The thought of a slightly easier, yet compelling as ever, Etrian game makes me smile a glorious smile of triumph: maybe I just found the perfect game to kill the pain of a summer that just ended, and going back to work, and, and.

All the above just to say: I'm going to buy EO3 no matter what.

So looking forward to this

I'm almost totally sure I will need to pick this game up. I think I played the 2nd installment over the course of, like, 3 months. The 3rd entry looks even slicker, and lesser difficulty or not, I can't wait.

I actually must admit, though, I would have preferred the game be made as equally difficult as the previous games, only because it's pretty much why I enjoy playing them. It's what they have going for them. The surge and the rush of triumph over ridiculous odds!

Anyway, great review, hopefully I can clear my gaming schedule for the release of this. We shall see.

Haha… well, just because

Haha… well, just because it's the easiest, that doesn't mean that it's *easy*…. I mean, don't get me wrong, this is probably the best place for newcomers to start, but the challenge level is still way, way up there. It's just not as instantly fatal as the last two. ^_^

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.